The 10 Best Garter Toss Songs of All Time When Does the Garter Toss Happen? The Garter Girl Now that's how to remove a garter! . Repost @someonesaidyes If you're going to remove your partner's garter, you should do it with some style! Leo and his pit crew had it Do You Have to do the Garter Toss? The Garter Girl The garter toss is a wedding tradition where the groom removes the bride's garter during the reception and tosses it to a group of single male guests, similar to the bridal bouquet toss, with the